New_ Public’s Eli Pariser Delivers a Speech at the Vatican Featuring Front Porch Forum
Eli Pariser is an author, activist, and entrepreneur focused on how to make technology and media serve democracy. He helped lead MoveOn.org, co-founded Upworthy, wrote “The Filter Bubble,” and is currently Co-Director of New_ Public. He has highlighted Front Porch Forum in numerous pieces and conversations, shining a light on its ability to lead to healthier communities thanks to its intentional design.
You can imagine our surprise – and delight – when he delivered a powerful speech to an audience that included Pope Francis at the Vatican’s Jubilee of the World of Communications – and put Front Porch Forum at the heart of his argument for “why we shouldn’t give up on the Internet.”
Here’s a highlight:
In Vermont, a small state in the northeast of the United States, people use Facebook and TikTok but town conversation mostly doesn’t happen there. They have something more like an actual digital town square — a home-grown social network called Front Porch Forum built specifically for the purpose of allowing towns to have good discussions.
Front Porch Forum has never taken venture capital and isn’t seeking to make a ton of money from advertisers. In fact, it’s a public benefit corporation that is not intended to make more money than is required to sustain itself. It’s always been built not for advertisers but to serve communities in Vermont first. And as a result, it can do conversations differently.
Because it doesn’t need to worry primarily about advertisers or engagement, instead of optimizing for the most posts possible, FPF optimizes for thoughtfulness — by updating only once a day. It’s a bold statement that says: slow down. Think about what you’re saying. And say something meaningful. And among other things, it makes having a flame war really arduous, because you have to be willing to carry it on for days at a time.
One of the things that FPF shows us is that these aren’t places we need to spend a lot of time for them to change us and foster stronger communities.
In our offline lives, places of worship are a great example of this: Even among the faithful, there are few that spend a large proportion of our time literally inside a church or synagogue or mosque or temple. But the parts of us that are nourished by these spaces remain fortified when we leave.
The same is true of the digital public spaces — we don’t need to vanquish Meta or TikTok entirely to make digital space building worth doing. People use Instagram in Vermont too… but FPF adds to their lives.
Front Porch Forum also puts its money where its mouth is when it comes to stewardship — in fact, while only a tiny fraction of people at TikTok or Meta work as moderators, at the 40-person organization of Front Porch Forum, half of the employees are paid moderators.
With this ratio of stewards to content, every single message can be read before it reaches everyone else to make sure it conforms to the very clear and thoughtful set of norms that have been co-developed over 20 years with community members. And when messages don’t — which happens sometimes — they don’t just disappear. Instead, you get a friendly note from one of the stewards asking you to phrase things differently.
And so, conversation goes better. People know their neighbors better. Communities are healthier. We conducted survey research on Front Porch Forum’s impact and found that not only did people across the political spectrum and across demographics like it much more than Facebook or Nextdoor, they also got more involved in the life of their town and were more committed neighbors as a result.
Of course, Front Porch Forum only exists in one small state in the United States. In most places around the country and the globe, these local conversations happen in forums like Facebook Groups and Nextdoor that are much less well designed for this purpose. But at New_ Public, the nonprofit R&D lab I run, we think Front Porch Forum is on to something big.
Read all about the experience in this New_ Public blog post.
Read the speech in its entirety here.
Watch and listen to Eli’s address (the bit about Front Porch Forum can be found at the 32-minute mark)
Lalee invited members of the Craftsbury Forum to get creative this month. We thought their posting was well worth a share:
“National Haiku Writing Month is here! Rev your pens, sharpen your pencils, get ready, get set, go! I’ll post a digested list of prompts each week, you bring your curiosity and creativity to the page. (Haiku is a short, Japanese-style poem of only three lines. It’s generally ruled by a syllable count of 5 syllables in the first line, 7 in the second, and 5 in the third.)
Thursday: fortitude
Friday: clarity
Saturday: gravity
Sunday: ravenous
Monday: peculiar
Tuesday: quandary
Wednesday: stampede
Craftsbury’s Third Annual Haiku Slam to follow!”
Ann took solace in a lovely winter scene and shared it on the South Hero Forum. We thought it was well worth a share:
“To whoever was playing ice hockey alone at 5 pm today (Sunday) — pretty far out, halfway between Apple Island Marina and Paradise Bay — thank you. It was beautiful to watch and lifted my mood.”
Dana shared this lovely story on their Montpelier Forum. We thought it was well worth a share:
“We came home this evening to find a sweet surprise pinned to our mailbox: a Ziploc bag of cookies and an index card reading, ‘I know that love is ultimately the only answer to mankind’s problems.’ – MLK Jr., plus many hand-drawn hearts and the words ‘Peace on Earth’ in glittery gel pen.
I might have a guess as to which neighbor brought this gift, or I might not. Whoever you are, thank you for your mysterious generosity on a single-digit night.”
It’s not uncommon to read “Thanks for helping me to get my car out of a ditch” appreciations on Front Porch Forum. But, we thought the responses to Rich’s posting in the Huntington Forum expressing gratitude to UPS driver, CJ, were well worth a share:
“CJ is the best delivery driver you will ever meet and a rather great human in general.” – Matthew
“CJ, our UPS driver, is indeed the best. He is also an author, check out his book ‘Palmer’s Acquisition.'” – Don
“He’s one of our unsung heroes. He’s an excellent problem solver. And even when there’s no problem to solve, I look forward to his arrival at Sleepy Hollow because he has such a warm, easy presence and knows so much about the region’s people and places.” – Carol
“He always calls us if he has to leave a package at the base of our driveway at night. Who does that?” – Melissa
“We have enjoyed his company and friendship over the last few years, He brought our son a tiny UPS truck for his birthday, I thoroughly enjoyed his book ‘Palmers Acquisition,’ and I recommend you read it!” – Casey
Jeff turned to his Burlington Forum when he and his wife welcomed their baby before they expected. We thought his post was well worth a share:
“I wanted to write a quick note of gratitude; the response to our ‘Oh no, we don’t have any onesies that fit our preemie baby!’ request for help was overwhelming. So many kind people drove through the snow on short notice to give us their hand-me-downs; so many people shared stories of their own very tiny babies growing up big and strong. I’m tearful thinking of the generosity and care, and am so thankful to live in this community and city.”
In many towns, there’s a call to deliver Christmas trees to local farms for goats to enjoy eating. Mari, in Shelburne, invited neighbors to deliver theirs to Merrymac Farm Sanctuary in Charlotte (for the 10 rescued sheep and 14 goats who think Christmas trees are delicious) or to drop them in their driveway.
Meanwhile, her husband, Will, was not up to date on reading his FPF issues. We thought his follow up was well worth a share:
“For the record, I have no problem with the town-wide invitation sent by my wife to put all your old Christmas trees in my driveway. While we didn’t talk about it in advance, now that I understand why all these trees are stacking up; I’m fully supportive for the cause of these animals.”
FPF members in Calais can rely on their neighbor, Don, for year-round sports updates – but most particularly hockey. We thought this year’s season preview was well worth a share:
“With last season’s efforts behind them with a handful of wins and an early playoff exit, this year’s crop of skaters has the vision and desire to turn things around in a big way. The three lone Seniors of Max Scribner, Maddox Heise, and Colton Warren spent their summer playing with a Vermont team that more than held their own vs. all-star teams from around New England. Add to that trio a group of 9 Freshmen who are coming off a State Championship last winter, and U32 might surprise the rest of the Division 2 league.
Shock might be a better word than surprise as this Raider team knocked off CVU, 5-0 in their first game. CVU is a perennial Div. 1 power and U32 overpowered them. With Milton, Harwood, and Stowe next in line, this younger version of U32 hockey will have a good idea of where they stand very soon.
Some of the best parts of sports often get hidden behind the headlines. Last year one forward reached the rare milestone of 100 career points with his linemate just a couple points away from joining him. With 2 assists in his first game, he reached that goal only to find out after the game his 100th point was changed to a Freshman player for his first point. The Senior player refused his 100-point banner and a photo in the paper and gave the point credit to the Freshman. A class act for the younger kids to follow and, most likely a banner celebration in the next game. Who said hockey rinks are cold!”
#vermont #vermonthockey #u32 #community #highschoolhockey #frontporchforum
Stephanie in Pittsford posted in her FPF, turning an unfortunate injury into holiday cheer for others. We thought it was well worth a share:
“I recently posted that my mom broke her wrist at the beginning of her wreath making season and was left with over 50 bundles of balsam that she had trucked down from Nova Scotia. So many people came forward to buy balsam and/or send messages of concern and support!
My mom didn’t want to sell the balsam for what she paid for it. She just wanted to recoup some of her loss. The folks who stopped in to buy balsam were so kind to her and she wanted me to let you know how much it means to her. She enjoyed meeting you and is so thankful for your kindness.”
“Best of FPF” is a series where we share one posting each Thursday from an FPF member who inspired us with their humor, community-mindedness, or just has a good story. Courtney submitted a posting in her Barre Town Forum that tugged on our heartstrings. We thought it was well worth a share:
“Missing mini piglet on Tamarack Lane. Her name is Lulu and she is very friendly. She weighs 21 pounds. Lulu loves carrots, celery, and all berries — and she is SO MISSED. She may be under a deck or under patio furniture cushions trying to keep warm.”
Courtney followed up with, “It has been completely heartwarming to have received so much love via messages, texts–and seeing so many people out searching in the dark for our sweet Lulu. We’ve hired a thermal drone service and I just want to post so everyone will know WHY there is a drone in our area today.”
Ghost of Midnight is an online journal about fostering community within neighborhoods, with a special focus on Front Porch Forum (FPF). My wife, Valerie, and I founded FPF in 2006... read more