Category Archives: Community Building

Local Online: Monolithic vs. Decentralized

Posted on Tuesday, November 13, 2007 by 2 comments

Kirby Winfield offers a good post today, for as far as it goes, about helping people connect to their local communities through the internet…

It’s been said that individuals today are increasingly disconnected from their communities. They are “bowling alone”; i.e., although the number of people who bowl has increased in the last 20 years, the number of people that bowl in leagues has decreased. Since people bowl alone they do not participate in social interaction and civic discussions that might occur in a league environment.

The Internet has been criticized for its isolating impact on society. In many cases increased engagement in online activities results in exacerbation of the “bowling alone” phenomenon.

There is a huge market void in local online media. With the exception of business search/reviews, no one has solved for community connection and conversation at the neighborhood or town level at scale. This brings me to the opportunity of “digitizing local.”

Some of the most passionate and well informed citizens in the country still communicate about their communities through print newsletters, in person meetings, and other offline means. These people thrive on being active locally. If you can somehow harness their knowledge, energy, and networks, you can create a vast forum of local influencers and relevant evergreen local content…

This, of course, is exactly what Front Porch Forum is all about in the 19 Vermont towns that comprise greater Burlington.

He goes one to say that no one has cracked this mystery at scale.  Perhaps that’s the wrong way to look at it.  Kind of like saying that none of the big box retailers have yet to really feel like a valuable local business.  It could be that, when it comes to local, the internet will deliver on its promise of decentralization and small scale and we’ll see thousands of super-valuable local sites rising up, each unique to their own special community… not the one-size-fits-all big box approach emanating from Silicon Valley.  Kind of like 100 years ago when every town had its own stand-alone, locally owned, daily newspaper.

Of course, the chains came along and gobbled up those papers eventually and left us with the USAToday model.

Maybe the internet will help usher back true local flavor and thousands of successful local media companies that enliven and enrich their home towns in ways that no clever distant mashup could ever achieve.

Playborhood Aims to Set our Kids Free

Posted on Monday, November 12, 2007 by No comments yet

Mike Lanza and some friends have created something called Playborhood.com

As parents of toddlers and babies, we’re concerned about whether we can provide a better life for our children than we had.  We’ve certainly done well financially – better than our parents, by and large – so we can provide an abundance of material goods for our children.  However, we weren’t hurting at all for material goods when we were kids, but we find that kids of today are sorely lacking in what was the greatest joy of our childhoods:  free, unstructured play.

Free, unstructured play (or what we refer to as simply “play”) has virtually vanished from the lives of most children in America.  We are committed to doing whatever we can to bring it back for our children and yours.

At Playborhood.com we will to build a community of parents in the United States, if not the world, that will become more aware of this problem, discuss solutions, and implement the best of those solutions.

This issue also motivates me in part to pursue Front Porch Forum.  I commented on Mike’s piece here.

Enabling People to be Good Neighbors

Posted on Sunday, November 11, 2007 by No comments yet

Poor Julia wrote to her FPF neighborhood forum the other day after her friend’s car was vandalized on her watch. Now tonight she follows up…

Thanks all you neighbors who contacted me with ways to help my friend whose car got keyed while under my care… and those who just wanted to send their condolences. I have to say, I love Front Porch Forum! We also found our lovely new apartment through this forum! Nothing but good things has come of being a part of it and I appreciate all of you who participate and make it a little more wonderful.

Westford Open for Deliberation

Posted on Sunday, November 11, 2007 by No comments yet

Westford, Vermont makes excellent use of Front Porch Forum, with about 25% of the households on board and lots of lively conversation. Currently, folks are debating using Town Meeting vs. an Australian ballot to decide the school budget every year. Beth weighed in today…

I would also love to see the Front Porch Forum continue to be a place where the information and debate about town issues gets talked about. It would be great to have reminders for upcoming regular town meetings, including agendas, posted here. I find this forum such a great resource and feel like it could be used to persuade people to become more involved in the decisions that shape our community. This was evident in the lively debate that happened here about the School Unification.

Smalltown becoming one with locals

Posted on Thursday, November 8, 2007 by No comments yet

I’ve noted before that Smalltown.com is one of the few local online efforts that is working on a model that is both authentically local and scalable. Most local online efforts seem to fall either in the “one off” mom-and-pop side or the “local, as in WalMart is local because they have a store on the edge of your town.” Smalltown is aiming between these two extremes with early signs of success… good for them.

Today we hear from their blog

In light of the recent histories of InsiderPages, Backfence and Judy’s Book, it’s gratifying to be thriving long enough to sponsor a major local event two years in a row. Our Series A has gotten us far, including the ability to hand out 500 It’s-It treats to kids in our neighborhood.

I’ve always believed that you can’t do local advertising from afar. A salesperson in a call center in Florida who calls a restaurant in San Mateo will reach the hostess who takes dinner reservations; not the owner who buys ads. Our sales people walk or drive to the restaurant to try the food and talk to the manager. Furthermore, when we knock on their doors they see us as people in their community; not carpetbaggers rolling through town to sell them junk. It takes time and money to gain the trust of local business owners, but once you do you have a customer for life.

Although different to Smalltown in many ways, Front Porch Forum has a similar approach, aiming to retain the local bona fides of a mom-and-pop while scaling up. And we’re finding our local businesses very open to our initial advertising opportunities.

Zilok does peer rental

Posted on Monday, November 5, 2007 by 1 comment

TechCrunch writes today about Zilok.com, a French start up now in the United States that facilitates people renting stuff from strangers… kind of like eBay, but you get the things back.  The comments mention several competitors doing the same thing.

Front Porch Forum sees a lot of exchanges like this among nearby neighbors, but without the rental fee.  We like to call it “borrowing something from the neighbor.”  Some readers with long memories may remember such a practice from days of yore.  And, while borrowing, you actually get to know the people who live around you a little better.  Gadzooks!

FPF ads strike a chord

Posted on Monday, November 5, 2007 by No comments yet

We’ve been getting very positive feedback on the ads running on Front Porch Forum.  And a certain amount of community pride seems to kick in when a particular neighborhood forum really catches hold.  Here’s a note from the ONE Central Neighborhood Forum in Burlington’s North End today…

Just wanted to say well done to all who post here and those who run and advertise on this forum. From what I’ve learned talking to other folks this is the liveliest front porch around. Its great to see a neighborhood dialogue happening.

Constructive War Talk among Neighbors

Posted on Thursday, November 1, 2007 by 1 comment

I love learning things from neighbors on Front Porch Forum… including how to keep an open mind. Here’s a glance at a discussion over the past few days on one of the Old North End neighborhood forums in Burlington, VT.

First from Marissa… she posted about the cost of the Iraq war in dollars appropriated by Congress for each county in Vermont…

With the latest Bush Administration’s request, the total war spending in fiscal year 2008 would be nearly $200 billion, with the vast majority going towards the Iraq War. If Congress passes this proposal, total Iraq War spending would rise to $611 billion.

For Vermont:
Appropriated $663 million
FY2008 New Requests $226 million
New Possible Total $889.1 million

Cost of proposed new requests to CITIES/COUNTIES IN VT
Burlington: $11,700,000
Chittenden County: $63,500,000

Then Chris took her to task…

You know it’s interesting you mention that, did you ever think how much the war would’ve cost if the country was united behind the war and freeing the Iraqi’s from not only Saddam, but the Al Quida in Iraq?

Let’s see, surely, the Al Quida would’ve given up by now, seeing how there was no bleeding heart’s in America decrying the war and Democrats crying for soldiers to come home and Bush’s expulsion… You know, it seems to this 20 year veteren of the military and Veteren of Desert Storm, that the “Vietnam syndrome” wouldn’t have been the case senario. Don’t think for a second that isn’t true…

Which brought many predictable responses against the war, including some particularly compelling ones, like this from Paula…

I am a part of a military family, dating back to the Civil War. My grandfather (bless his heart) was dropped on the beaches of Normandy, watching his fellow men get shot to bits. He served again in the Korean War. When Vietnam loomed around the corner, he told his superiors that it was not a war he agreed with and he also didn’t want to take his third chance. With promises of making him a 2 Star General, he decided to retire, with honors, including three purple hearts.

When I asked him what he thought about this war/mess, he just silently shook his head back and forth. “I’m ashamed for this country. We have lost our national face on this. Nothing will ever be the same, except there will be more hatred in this world. And, mark my words, it will not just be from other countries, a majority of it will come from us and pointing the finger at each other; who’s right and who’s wrong. I’m sorry that you and future generations will have to deal with this mess.”

So, to Chris, what do you propose to make this easier for future generations? I just heard a lot of (hateful) words, but nothing of solid worth. And, this forum is for any issues that adults would like to talk about.

While the conversation grew heated, it never erupted into a full-fledged flame war. Chris really knocked my socks off with his follow up…

I must admit, I kind of knew I’d be stoking a fire, but I feel so strongly this way. My post wasn’t meant to involk hate, just express the endless frustrations of the missed opportunity to win this war so long ago. I admit, I view protesting as a right of the United States, but, still, I can’t help feeling the same anger I felt when I was in the first war. When I was in Saudi, durring Storm, the Burlington Free Press would be forwarded to our area. The news always carried pictures of those in front of the Post Office, or those in front of the Unitarian Church, decrying the war. My heart hurt…that’s no lie.

I still carry these feeling inside of me and feel the only way to support the troops, is to ease off on the public negitivity towards the Iraqi campaign. I have a whole company of friends that went to Iraq . This, two weeks after my retirement became final. I wanted so much to jump out there with a sign to support the war and the troops, but I kept my distance. I do apologize for over reacting, but you need to know the man behind the pain.

My National Guard company has recently returned, making me feel good that all are in one piece. I can’t for the life of it suddenly denounce my feelings. If I trounced on someone else’s feelings, that wasn’t meant. It just that soldiers are human too. They see and hear (the news) on the radio and television. Maybe we in Vermont should be aware of this fact. Thank you.

A sane, respectful, constructive conversation about a gut-wrenchingly divisive issue with hundreds of nearby neighbors listening in and several commenting.  I don’t see anything like this on the blogosphere, talk radio or the letters-to-the-editor pages.  This kind of exchange, unlike the polarizing stuff I see elsewhere, fills me with hope and glimmers of understanding of other viewpoints.

Economic Development through FPF

Posted on Wednesday, October 31, 2007 by No comments yet

Amy Kirschner writes in Money in the Mountains this month…

Getting to know your neighbors leads to economic opportunities…

If you’re a Burlington resident, you’ve probably heard of Front Porch Forum. The service was started in the Five Sisters neighborhood by Michael Wood-Lewis and his wife, Valerie as a way for neighbors to share news by email.

Front Porch Forum has gotten a lot of press and recognition lately as a community building tool. It’s interesting that beyond building social capital, being neighborly and coming together on community projects, members have found FPF to also be a place to be creative economically.

In the Old North End Central neighborhood, the Soup Mama, started a business delivering soup to neighbors – by bike! – and has been advertising weekly on the forum. A student has taken the fundraising-for-a-school-trip-bake-sale online by offering pumpkin pies delivered to your door the week before Thanksgiving.

Testimonials featured on the website list people who have found plumbers, bought and sold homes, and found tenants for rental properties.

Many of us have skills that we couldn’t pursue full time in the market economy but that could be used to supplement our income. People can sometimes find communities of interest online or in their area that might make a transaction possible, but Front Porch Forum has made it possible to market those skills to your geographical community.

To strengthen and diversify our local economy, there are two strategies we must pursue: creating the capital and creating the market. Front Porch Forum has filled a gap in marketing and exchanging services among neighbors while building community.

Pickle the Cat Reunited after Crosstown Jaunt

Posted on Friday, October 26, 2007 by No comments yet

I’ve always wondered about those stories of pets finding their way across unfamiliar terrain to get back home.  Now we have a Front Porch Forum version.  First, Lara posted her “lost cat” announcement on her new neighborhood’s forum and got no response.  Then, she got it posted on an FPF neighborhood forum in Burlington’s South End…

I moved from Adams Street [in the south end] last month to Rose Street in the north end. Since Monday night (10/15), my cat Pickle has been missing. He’s a black and grey tiger-striped short hair. He’s long, lean, and very soft. He’s also double-pawed (he has extra toes that make it looks like he has thumbs). He may be making his way back to our old place.  Photos on MySpace and SnapFish.  Please call with ANY sightings at 802-318-6125. Thank you!

Now today we see…

The Cat Came Back!  Actually, Pickle didn’t technically come back. He went all the way to our old place on Adams Street in the south end! It took him 10 days, but the new tenant Rebecca called me this morning to say that Pickle was on her front porch. He’s healthy (not a scratch), happy, and finally home. THANK YOU to everyone who contacted me with possible Pickle sightings. We moved to ONE a month ago, and I can’t tell you how much it means to me that my new neighbors are so thoughtful. And yay Front Porch Forum!!